Reese's

(2 Pack) Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter, 18 oz (2 pack)

$5.55
(4) 4 stars out of 10 reviews 10 reviews
$5.55
$5.55
Free overnigh delivery
FSA and HSA eligible
(2 Pack) Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter, 18 oz (2 pack)

Notice unusual marketplace activity?

Report

Customer reviews & ratings

4 out of 5stars
(10 reviews)

Most helpful positive review

5.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
07/04/2021
Good Stuff, Get Some
Love this stuff. Only issue is I wish it was available in larger jars. I've been a Jiff guy my whole life so that's my fall back if this isn't available. Its hard to describe why I like it so much so just give it a try for yourself and see.
Steven

Most helpful negative review

1.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
12/20/2021
Misleading
The peanut butter itself is not BAD. But it is so misleading, as a consumer I was under the impression that it would be like the filling in peanut butter cups. I can't tell you how disappointed me and everyone else in my household was to taste this. Reese's have always been some of my favourite treats, but this made me lose a huge amount of respect for the company. Do better.
Reviewedbyme
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    12/20/2021
    Misleading
    The peanut butter itself is not BAD. But it is so misleading, as a consumer I was under the impression that it would be like the filling in peanut butter cups. I can't tell you how disappointed me and everyone else in my household was to taste this. Reese's have always been some of my favourite treats, but this made me lose a huge amount of respect for the company. Do better.
    Reviewedbyme
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    09/30/2021
    smooth, silky, delicious
    This peanut butter is really smooth and silky, and tastes great. It is as sweet as regular peanut butter, not super sweet like Reese's peanut butter cups.
    s
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    08/31/2021
    Great P-nut butter
    We love this p-nut butter can't get it in local stores.
    Sewlful
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    08/09/2021
    Hey super peanut butter for the most discriminatin
    Hey superb peanut butter for the most discriminating of tastes This is classic Reeses Smooth and creamy one of the top three peanut butters I use as a connoisseur of peanut butter the others being jiff and Skippy
    William
  • 2.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    07/25/2021
    To sweet
    son likes it but I don't think it taste like reeses
    Unknown
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    07/04/2021
    Good Stuff, Get Some
    Love this stuff. Only issue is I wish it was available in larger jars. I've been a Jiff guy my whole life so that's my fall back if this isn't available. Its hard to describe why I like it so much so just give it a try for yourself and see.
    Steven
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    04/17/2021
    NOT the Reese's Cup Filling, But a Decent PB
    This is NOT the same as a Reese's Cup filling, but good PB anyway. The Reese's PB cup has sort of a crumby texture and this PB is pure oily-creamy, kind of a mix of Peter Pan
    SportsCarDude
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    03/15/2021
    reeses peanut butter
    I luv this peanut butter. I buy it all the time
    Jess
  • 3.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    03/07/2021
    Not bad for regular peanut butter but
    It doesn't live up to its name like everyone else has said. I think they lack sugar and a few other ingredients found in the peanut butter in the cups. It is really just a jiffy grade peanut butter that costs more. Kinda disappointed. Proper fix is probably to add more molasses, more sugar, and possibly some brown sugar and make it a bit more gritty texture like the reese's peanut butter is. Plus add in like a chocolate shell on the outside as I think the hot chocolate on top of the reese's peanut butter cup carmelized the sugar, thus giving it an edge over this. You could also just fry this on a pan until it's carmelized a bit, than stir together.
    CosmicLightning
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    07/02/2016
    Best Peanut Butter EVER.
    This stuff is like Snapple. Made from the best stuff on earth. So much more peanut flavor than JIF and smoother than Peter Pan's baby butt, I dare you to find a better peanut butter than Reese's.
    Josh